Looking for a needle in a haystack
So Mike MacDougal is not the closer. That’s what Tony Pena says. It’s been an open competition all the while. he says. How so? MacDougal got sick in spring training and didn’t pitch for the last month or so in Surprise, Ari., and then had some up and down outings in the minors on a rehab stint. Once he was activated from the D.L, voila!, he was handed the job as closer.
To be fair, using Curt Leskanic in the role wasn’t working. But you’d think that they would have found some low-leverage situations for MacDougal to pitch in, to get his feet wet. Goodness knows, they’ve been behind in nearly every game. For the Royals, low-leverage situations abound. MacDougal went one ten day stretch where he pitched only one inning. The he was called into the middle of an inning and asked to protect a one-run lead with men on base. He failed, of course, and his confidence had to be shaken.
To make matters worse, Pena annoints Nate Field as the ‘backup closer’. No one yet has explained to me the role of ‘backup closer’ to the point that I can understand it.
That brings us to last night’s debacle. First, Pena leaves in Jeremy Affeldt too long. He can’t seem to find the middle ground – he either pulls pitchers too soon (<90 pitches) or too late (>120 pitches). Grimsley comes on and does a nice job of getting through the eighth inning with the lead still intact. But MacDougal makes short work of the lead by walking Johnny Damon and giving up a two-run blast to Mark Bellhorn.
A couple of things: MacDougal was getting squeezed by home-plate umpire Joe West. The same thing happened Monday night. My fear is that MacDougal’s reputation for wildness is so embedded that he doesn’t get border line pitches. Border line, hell. He doesn’t get pitches that are clearly strikes if they miss the target set up by the catcher. That was the case last night. Twice MacDougal threw strikes that Benito Santiago has to move his glove to catch. That’s what happens when your rep is that you can’t get the ball over the plate. But, still, MacDougal is not that far away – all the more reason to use him in low-leverage situations to get his mechanics in working order. Now, though, with his confidence roughly worth a unit of Enron stock, it might take him a half-season to straighten out.
Scott Sullivan came in after MacDougal. What happened to Field? Well, I guess once MacDougal gave up the leads, it was no longer a save situation. Hence, no need for a ‘backup closer’. When will managers forget about the fucking save rule (it was made up by a sports writer!) and just use their best relievers in the situations where they can do the most good? Pena’s mismanagement of the bullpen has been egregious this season. It was last season, as well. But since he falls into lockstep with the post-Eckersley school of bullpen management, he removes the onus from himself. Nope, it’s Mike MacDougal who is getting skewered. It’s MacDougal who is being dipped in tar while the chickens are being plucked.
And you know what? MacDougal never had a chance.